Shoukoku no Altair First Impressions (1): Birds are stronger than I expected

Click here to check this post out on my personal website.

Ahh crap…am I just giving myself another opportunity to show off my complete lack of historical knowledge? I don’t know how accurate this series is, but Turkey seems like a new and interesting place to use as a setting. The political setup in this first episode was pretty interesting to watch. The series introduces us to a tension between two nations and shows us potential enemies on both sides. I wasn’t expecting the conflict in this first episode to resolve itself, but I guess the series needed to show off Mahmut’s skills a bit.

I thought this scene was funnier than it probably should have been. Mahmut’s reaction to seeing a dancer in his bed is to hide on the roof. But more to the point, this part of the episode marked a pretty sudden tone change. Before this point, the episode seemed like a lighthearted introduction for Mahmut, but then it immediately jumps into a fight between Mahmut and a random thief the next day. After that scene ends, we’re suddenly in war talks.

The biggest nagging point for me in this episode, though, has to be Mahmut’s investigation into the assassination. I had a lot of trouble believing that the arrow Mahmut needed to examine was just sitting around for him to find. It’s also possible that the arrow in the church was a normal arrow that made Mahmut realize the discrepancy, but then you’d have to explain how Mahmut saw the arrow used to kill Franz.

I also thought that the way that Halil explained the Empire’s position in the carriage with Mahmut was a nice touch. It served to introduce the Empire as the major political force in the area, and Halil was able to draw an interesting conclusion from the subterfuge used to provoke a war. It also explained the confusing council meeting near the beginning of the episode. If the Empire has the superior political position, it makes more sense for Turkiye to cater to its demands.

In all, this episode had its issues, but it still looked promising. I think I’m interested enough to keep watching more.


2 thoughts on “Shoukoku no Altair First Impressions (1): Birds are stronger than I expected”

  1. To address the point you brought up, I think they explained that the arrow was sent back to Turkey with a letter. It’s possible. Not exactly sure why it was right where he was pondering, but it wasn’t too unreasonable for him to find it.

    I also thought that the initial problem was wrapped up a little too quickly, but the series looks really interesting to me so far and I’m looking forward to more.


    1. yup, i looked back and the arrow was sent back to turkey. but yeah, no idea why they cleaned it up and put it on display when it was an item that nearly started a war.

      i kinda figured that they didnt want the first big thing in the show to be locked in suspense, but yeah it was pretty quick


Leave your comments here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s